Insured both Myself (spritely 38) and the Ministry of disinformation (BIG Four - oh soon!) - £199.38 fully comp.
We both have other cars which we have full no claims on (well 4 between us) - but NCD cannot be transferred between vehicles, and we both earn NCD on the Fronty for the future on this policy as she is a named driver (handy when Mel insures Cathrine when she is old enough as Mels 'proper NCD wont be affected in the event of a claim).
Fully comp was indeed cheaper than 3rd party fire and theft for some reason (and it was discounted even further with a named driver living at the same address??)
Tried all the online places and gave up and went to a Broker (Swintons) who came up with the best price - as your dealing with a human being and can explain its a weekend fun car - not an everyday form of transport, and basically it needs to be insured to get where your going.... and hopefully back

Policy is with 'Premier' - £50 excess for damage claims, windscreen and legal cover too.
Cant be bad!
John & Mel